Heads up–Four Giraffa species have distinct cranial morphology

DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0315043Read our scientific commentary

Research by

Nikolaos Kargopoulos, Jesús Marugán‐Lobón, Anusuya Chinsamy, Bernard Agwanda, Michael B. Brown, Stephanie Fennessy, Sara Ferguson, Rigardt Hoffman, Fredrick Lala, Arthur Muneza, Ogeto Mwebi, Moses Otiende, Alice Petzold, Sven Winter, Abdoul Razack Moussa Zabeirou, Julian Fennessy

Provides a 515-skull three-dimensional dataset connecting sex, size and developmental variation with morphological differences among preassigned giraffe taxonomic groups.

Study summary

A giraffe’s forehead helps reveal which species it belongs to. The difference lies partly in the bony projection between the eyes, beyond the familiar paired structures on top of the head. Genetic research had supported four species, but the question remained whether their skulls also carried a consistent anatomical signature.

Nikolaos Kargopoulos, Jesús Marugán-Lobón and colleagues assembled 515 skulls from museum collections, African parks and reserves, and taxidermy collections. They made three-dimensional scans, marked corresponding points across each skull and compared shapes among groups. Because male giraffe heads grow larger and develop more prominent bony structures, the analyses also examined sex, growth and the influence of size on shape.

All four species differed statistically in cranial shape. The central forehead projection was particularly informative: it tended to be tall and pointed in northern males, lower and broader in reticulated males, smaller in Masai males, and faint or almost absent in southern males. Females showed subtler differences. Individuals still varied and overlapped, so these are not infallible visual identification rules. Instead, many small measurements revealed a repeated anatomical pattern: the genetic divisions have a counterpart in the shape of giraffes’ heads.

Summary by The Last Giraffe

Publication details

Study facts

Method
Cross-sectional three-dimensional geometric morphometrics with size regression, principal components and discriminant analyses.
Location
Museum collections and wild-collected or taxidermy material representing giraffe ranges across Africa.
Species
Authors' four-species framework: Giraffa camelopardalis, G. reticulata, G. tippelskirchi and G. giraffa.
Sample
515 assembled skulls: 363 museum specimens, 70 park/reserve samples and 82 taxidermy specimens; analysis subsets vary.
Period
Collection and scanning calendar dates are not compiled in the main Methods.

Full citation

Nikolaos Kargopoulos, Jesús Marugán‐Lobón, Anusuya Chinsamy, Bernard Agwanda, Michael B. Brown, Stephanie Fennessy, Sara Ferguson, Rigardt Hoffman, Fredrick Lala, Arthur Muneza, Ogeto Mwebi, Moses Otiende, Alice Petzold, Sven Winter, Abdoul Razack Moussa Zabeirou, Julian Fennessy (2024). Heads up–Four Giraffa species have distinct cranial morphology. PLoS ONE. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0315043

Open the original publication